Application Request Routing broken in IIS 7

Application request routing module within IIS 7 is completely broken and impossible to access. Clicking through the GUI in IIS Manager yields an error.

This seems to only be an issue on Windows Server 2012 and does not seem to be happening on Windows Server 2016. Leading me to think this could maybe be a patching issue.

Error: There was an error while performing this operation.

Details: The object identifier does not represent a valid object. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x800710D8)